Questions Like if a Tree Falls in the Forest

Are there more examples of questions like If a tree falls in the forest will it make a sound. My answer is always a combination of me shouting in my head YES OF COURSE and me saying Yes Now if nobody heard me would I have said yes.

Indestructible Lenses The Far Side Far Side Comics Far Side Cartoons

Questions Like If A Tree Falls In The Forest.

. If a Tree Falls in the Forest. I am not a philosopher so I suspect you will get better answers. If a tree falls in the forest and no one is around to hear it does it make a noise.

Completely independent of whether or not there is an observer. If you make movement you disturb matter which transfers energy in the form of sound. The first riddle originates in a slightly different form from a June 1883 edition of a magazine called The Chautauquan.

I would like to add a second thought. The whole if a tree falls in the forest and no one is around to hear it does it make a sound question has never made any sense to me. The second riddle is a question that is said to have been asked by Albert Einstein to Niels Bohr.

But given the way the distinction is generally made it seems more profitable to reform the original question. The popular Zen koan goes If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it does it make a sound Much ink has been spilt around this aphorism but my. Even if theres no person or other animal around to hear the sound a recorder with a microphone could certainly record those vibrationsas sound.

If a tree falls in the forest and no one is around to hear it does it make a sound if youve ever heard this famous question originally posed by philosopher george berkeley then youve actually already been introduced to the subjectivism vs. Posted Jan 26 2021. If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it does it make a sound S ince this same example and question came up twice in three days in private conversation I thought it might be useful to translate into a blog post.

However before you can understand my stance I first need to define two critical. The answer is unequivically yes. If a tree falls in the forest and no one is around to hear it does it make a sound If youve ever heard this famous question originally posed by philosopher George Berkeley then youve actually already been introduced to the subjectivism vs.

If you would like to support the project please visit the project page where you can get more details on how you can help and where you can join the general discussion about philosophy content on Wikipedia. Posted by udeleted 10 years ago. Did Berkeley really ask the question about the tree in the forest.

If a tree falls etc etc does it. Did bishop Berkeley actually write the question if a tree fell in the forest and no one was present to hear it would there be a sound. When a tree falls in the woods and there is no one there to hear it does it make a sound.

Does it make noise. If this joke is told in a forest and no one hears. This is because on one is in the forest waiting for the sound to be perceived.

Are there more examples of questions like If a tree falls in the forest will it make a sound. Everybody has probably heard the question If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it does it make a sound This question pisses me off to some extent. Answer 1 of 3.

But basically the question is is sound an objective fact or not Is sound sound just because we call it by that name Or are the waves in air that are created by a tree falling sound in and of themselves. This question is a popular philosophical question that scholars have been asking since the 1700s. Objectivism debate perhaps without realizing it.

TalkIf a tree falls in a forest. The question When a tree falls in a lonely forest and no animal is near by to hear it. No doubt youve been in on the debate probably in school with regards to the question If a tree falls in the forest and nobodys around to hear it.

Wikipedia even has a page dedicated to the topic. In a good way though. If a tree falls in the forest it makes a sound even if nobody is around to hear it.

Wikipedia the free encyclopedia. No more water in the pail. When other people start getting interested the original song becomes popular and over played the same person than blogs about what big sell-outs theyve become.

The tree and forest is dependent on minds but even in the absence of human minds an all seeing mind holds the forest and falling tree in existence so that the qualia of the falling tree noise still exists even when no. If nobody is looking at the moon does it exist. Yes Alvin it seems that Bishop Berkeley did raise this.

If sound is vibrations then the falling tree certainly does make a sound because it produces vibrations in the air. Answer by Tony Fahey. I feel that the tree would not make a sound if it were to fall in a forest.

If there be no ears to hear there will be no sound The current phrasing appears to have originated in the 1910 book Physics by Charles Riborg Mann and George Ransom Twiss. Is it real until you tell someone about it. The falling of the tree or any other disturbance will produce vibration of the air.

Get outside when we feel like it.

If A Tree Falls In A Forest And No One S There To Hear It Does It Make A Sound Better Questions For Landscape Artwork Landscape Paintings Winter Landscape

Pin On Comics That Make Me Lol

Pin By Ralphup On Gary Larson Comic Art Painting Comics

If A Tree Falls In The Forest And No One Is There To Hear It Does It Make A Sound George Berkeley Matter Science Reality

Tree Facts Comprehension Mini Book Mini Books Comprehension Tree

Pin On Makes Me Laugh

If A Tree Falls In A Forest And No One Is Around To Hear It Does It Make A Sound Funny Facebook Status Funny Pictures For Facebook Modern Philosophy

Pin By Sally Reid On Thangzzz Memes N Such Memes Really Funny Funny

If A Tree Falls In A Forest Funny Autumn Trees Best Funny Pictures Chalkboard Quote Art

If A Tree Falls In The Forest And Only A Red Stapler Hears It Autumn Trees Tree Tree Trunk

Pin On Garden Design

Q If A Tree Falls In A Forest And There S No One Around To Hear It Does It Make A Sound Nsta

Poor Tree Funny Pictures Funny I Love To Laugh

To Answer The Question If A Tree Falls In The Woods And Nobody Hears It Did It Happen Well Yes Hilariously I Took Myself Off Down A Dirt Track In A Fores